Rehab & Costs · Analysis

How to Calculate ARV for a Flip: The Comps Method, Step by Step

ARV is the price a flip should sell for after the rehab. Find recent closed comps, adjust for differences, then apply the average price per square foot.

By Flipper News Staff · · 4 min read

A magnifying glass held over a small wooden model of a house
Photo: Sasun Bughdaryan / Unsplash

Why it matters

  • ARV is estimated from closed sales of similar, renovated homes nearby. Fannie Mae requires appraisers to report at least three closed comps, generally from the last 12 months.
  • Adjust each comp's price for differences from your finished house, convert to price per square foot, average and multiply by your square footage.
  • ARV drives both your offer and your loan. The 70% rule multiplies it, and lenders such as Kiavi and New Silver cap loans at 80% and 75% of ARV.

Analysis: this piece includes our interpretation of the facts reported.

To calculate ARV (after-repair value) for a flip, find at least three recent closed sales of similar, renovated homes near your property. Adjust each sale price up or down for differences from your finished house, divide by each comp's square footage, average the results, and multiply by your house's square footage. That number is what the house should sell for after the rehab.

Run the numbers in our ARV from Comps tool, then carry the result into the free fix and flip calculator.

How do you calculate ARV for a flip?

Use this formula:

Adjusted price   = Comp sale price ± Adjustments
Adjusted $/sq ft = Adjusted price ÷ Comp square feet
ARV              = Average adjusted $/sq ft × Your finished square feet

The hard part is not the math. It is choosing the comps.

How to pick comps

Appraisers follow rules from Fannie Mae, and the lender's appraiser will check your ARV the same way.

  • Closed sales only. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide requires "a minimum of three closed comparables." Listings and contracts can be used only as supporting data.
  • Recency. Fannie Mae says comps that closed within the last 12 months should be used. In a market where prices are changing, the newest sales tell you the most, and any time adjustment must be supported by evidence.
  • Radius. Fannie Mae sets no fixed distance. It says comps should come from the subject's market area or subdivision when possible, and the appraiser must state each comp's distance in miles. Stay in the same neighborhood and school district before you widen the search.
  • Beds, baths and size. Match the room count and finished area of your house after the rehab. Fannie Mae requires appraisers to measure square footage with the ANSI standard and to report below-grade space, such as a basement, separately from above-grade living area.
  • Condition. Your comps must look like your house will look when it is done. On the Uniform Appraisal Dataset scale, C2 means entirely remodeled within 36 months, and C3 means most, but not all, major components updated. A house you buy at C5 or C6 should be compared with C2 or C3 sales, not with other fixer-uppers.

How do adjustments work?

Adjust the comp, never your house. If a comp is better than your finished house, subtract value. If it is worse, add value. Fannie Mae says adjustments "must reflect the market's reaction" and sets no limit on net or gross adjustments. It does not accept rule-of-thumb adjustments that conflict with market evidence. The best support is a pair of local sales that differ in just one feature, such as a garage.

A worked example

Hypothetical numbers, not market data. After the rehab, your house will have 1,500 square feet, three bedrooms, two baths and no garage.

CompSale priceDifferenceAdjustmentSq ftAdjusted $/sq ft
1$318,000MatchesNone1,480$214.86
2$299,0001.5 baths+$7,5001,420$215.85
3$335,000Has a garage−$10,0001,600$203.13

The average is about $211.28 per square foot. Times 1,500 square feet, that gives an ARV of about $317,000. Taken one at a time, the comps point to a range of about $305,000 to $324,000. A $360,000 listing down the street is left out, because it has not sold.

How does ARV feed the 70% rule?

The 70% rule sets a maximum offer of ARV × 0.70 minus repairs. With $45,000 of repairs:

$317,000 × 0.70 − $45,000 = $176,900

If the low comp is right and the ARV is $305,000, the maximum offer falls to $168,500. Every $10,000 of ARV error moves the offer by $7,000. Our guide to the 70% rule and ARV calculators covers the rule in more detail.

How do lenders use ARV?

Fix and flip lenders cap the loan at a share of ARV and a share of total cost. Kiavi's fix and flip page lists loans up to 80% of after-repair value. New Silver's help center lists up to 75% of ARV and up to 90% of loan to cost. Terms vary by borrower and deal.

In the example, with a $176,900 price and $45,000 rehab:

LimitLoan
75% of $317,000 ARV$237,750
80% of $317,000 ARV$253,600
90% of $221,900 cost$199,710

A loan cannot exceed either cap, so the smaller one controls. Here that is the cost cap. The lender's appraisal, not your spreadsheet, sets the ARV used. A low appraisal shrinks the ARV cap and can mean more cash at closing.

Margins leave little room for error. ATTOM said the typical flip in the second quarter earned a $60,526 gross profit, a 21.5% margin, before rehab and other costs, which it said flipping veterans estimate at 20% to 33% of ARV.

Find the rest of the calculators, sorted by stage of the flip, on our flipping tools page.

Sources

The Flip Sheet

Coming soon: a weekly email with new tools, deal data and rehab costs. Follow via RSS until it launches.

Follow via RSS